Mystery Accessory Box

$20.00



β™‘ π—ͺ𝗛𝗔𝗧 π—œπ—§ π—œπ—¦: Check out these fun Mystery Accessory Boxes! I don't know about you, but there's something about a "mystery" bag or box that gets me pretty excited and takes me right back to when I was a kid and choosing the perfect mystery bag from Claire's. With a variety of themed options to choose from, each box is carefully curated to offer you a unique and enjoyable surprise. Each box has at least six items in a fun variety - this is easily a $60+ value! Keep reading for more info on what you'll receive.

β™‘ π——π—˜π—§π—”π—œπ—Ÿπ—¦: There are several themes to choose from when selecting a Mystery Accessory Box! These items could be dangly earrings, stud earrings, planner clips/bookmarks, keychains, hair accessories, and/or necklaces.

β˜† Winter: The Winter Box is filled with all things wintery goodness, featuring patterns and color combinations that capture the essence of the season without themed pieces like Santa's or Candy Canes. Cozy up with stylish accessories that embrace the magic of winter.

β˜† Spring: Embrace the beauty of spring with our Spring Box, featuring soft pastels, florals, and all things soft and pretty. From delicate earrings to charming bookmarks, this box is sure to add a touch of elegance to your ensemble.

β˜† Summer: Get ready for fun in the sun with our vibrant Summer Box! Bursting with bright colors and playful designs, this box is perfect for adding a pop of energy to your summer wardrobe.

β˜† Fall: Transition into fall with our cozy Fall Box, showcasing warm neutrals, plaids, and possibly some charming leaves. Embrace the beauty of autumn with accessories that capture the essence of the season.

β˜† Back to School: Celebrate the start of a new school year with our Back to School Box, ideal for teacher & support staff as gifts or treating yourself if you're in a school setting!

β˜† Holiday: Prepare for the festivities with our Holiday Box, featuring themed pieces for many US holidays. Whether it's Valentine's Day, St. Patrick's Day, Easter, Memorial Day/4th of July, Halloween, Thanksgiving, or Christmas, this box has something for every occasion.

β˜† Just Surprise Me!: Can't decide? Opt for our Just Surprise Me! Box and let us curate a true assortment of items just for you. From themed pieces to a mixture of accessories, this box promises an exciting surprise every time. The "Just Surprise Me!" box may include seasonal pieces for upcoming holidays.

β€’ Most items will be genuine leather, but some may be faux leather, metals, wood, glass, resin/acrylic, or fabric.

β€’ Each Mystery Accessory Box will be one of a kind, if you choose multiple boxes - each will be unique!

β˜† psst - love this idea but feeling maybe overwhelmed by all the choices? I also offer earrings only mystery bags: https://www.myfriendsarahmadeit.com/listing/1114272200/mystery-earring-box-surprise-earrings

β™‘ Enjoy FREE standard shipping with a $35 purchase!

β™‘β™‘β™‘β™‘β™‘β™‘
Thank you so much! Please share and tag @myfriendsarahmadeit in your pictures on social media. I'd LOVE to see them!

Facebook: My Friend Sarah Made It
Instagram: @myfriendsarahmadeit


β™‘ 𝗩𝗔π—₯π—œπ—”π—§π—œπ—’π—‘π—¦ & 𝗩𝗔π—₯π—œπ—”π—•π—Ÿπ—˜π—¦: β™‘ Please note that cork and leather materials may display natural markings, textures, or visual irregularities. Cork often has natural pits or divots, and its color may vary around these areas. Additionally, for patterned materials, most pairs will not have identical left and right sides. As each item is handcrafted, minor inconsistencies between pairs may occur. However, all items are created using the same materials, ensuring cohesive pairs.

πŸ’Œ π—¦π—›π—œπ—£π—£π—œπ—‘π—š & π—£π—”π—–π—žπ—”π—šπ—œπ—‘π—š: πŸ’Œ My Friend Sarah Made It ships quickly! Most items are 'ready to ship,' so your order will be processed and shipped within 1-2 business days of purchase. Each order is carefully packaged in a box to ensure safe delivery. Multiple pairs of earrings will be shipped together in a larger box. All earrings are presented on branded cards and include backings.

πŸ“ π—’π—‘π—˜ 𝗠𝗒π—₯π—˜ π—§π—›π—œπ—‘π—š: πŸ“ Colors may appear differently on various devices. While I am not a professional photographer, I do aim to accurately capture colors in natural light with minimal editing! If you have any questions about colors or need more details, please reach out to me. After all, I want you to be thrilled with your order! All items are handcrafted in my smoke-free, pet-friendly home studio. 🐢🐱

Shipping from United States

Processing time

1-2 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept cancellations

Frequently Asked Questions

Custom and personalized orders

I love custom requests! Switching leather choices, hardware materials, or a completely unique design. Please message me to start your order!

β™‘ Custom orders must be paid in full before I order materials or begin working on your custom request.
β™‘ My turn around time is 10-14 business days as I will need to order materials (this TAT gives me time to order materials and have my supplier prepare & ship the order to me, and then create the earrings for you before mailing). Often times it's a lot sooner than the 10-14 days but USPS is really unpredictable right now.
β™‘ I'll send you photographs of everything before mailing for approval or changes.
β™‘ I won't directly copy another shops creations, but I can use lots of ideas as inspiration!

Care instructions

Accessories purchased from My Friend Sarah Made It are not meant to be worn 24/7. It's suggested you remove them prior to bathing, swimming, or sleeping.
β€’ Your sterling silver or brass pieces may tarnish over time. You can gently clean your pieces with a jewelry cloth to bring back the shine.
β€’ When not being worn, it's suggested you hang or lay flat.
β€’ Macrame earrings are typically sprayed with a starch spray to keep the fringe flat prior to shipping. With wear, they may soften and become tangled. You can gently brush with a fine toothed comb to flatten it back out.
β€’ Leather fringe earrings may curl with wear. If you'd like to straighten them back out, you can lay a heavy book on top of the leather portion.

Returns/Exchanges

Unfortunately, My Friend Sarah Made It cannot accept returns or exchanges due to hygiene risks. However PLEASE contact me with your concerns should any arise. If I'm able to make it right, I will!

What are your business hours?

β€’ MFSMI is a one woman shop and a busy mama to two sweet boys and I must maintain strict "office hours" to ensure I have time to help my guys with their needs as well.

β€’ "Office hours" are typically 8:30am EST - 1:30pm EST, Monday - Friday, excluding holidays. I will reply to any messages received after 8pm EST by the next business day.

β€’ I endeavor to ship within 1 to 2 business days of your order placement and ship Monday through Saturday (excluding holidays) for all ready to ship purchases and will contact you immediately via Etsy messages if that timeline changes (please see my "custom requests" FAQ for the timeline on custom pieces).

These mystery boxes are so much fun! I absolutely loved everything! I always love everything Sarah makes, and I really like surprises, so these were perfect as a birthday gift to myself. There were so many times in each box, and you can tell she put each box together with care and thought about the details. The handwritten note with each order is always appreciated, and she even included a free pair of stud earrings. I most definitely will be ordering from her again!


These mystery boxes are so much fun! I absolutely loved everything! I always love everything Sarah makes, and I really like surprises, so these were perfect as a birthday gift to myself. There were so many times in each box, and you can tell she put each box together with care and thought about the details. The handwritten note with each order is always appreciated, and she even included a free pair of stud earrings. I most definitely will be ordering from her again!


These mystery boxes are so much fun! I absolutely loved everything! I always love everything Sarah makes, and I really like surprises, so these were perfect as a birthday gift to myself. There were so many times in each box, and you can tell she put each box together with care and thought about the details. The handwritten note with each order is always appreciated, and she even included a free pair of stud earrings. I most definitely will be ordering from her again!


These mystery boxes are so much fun! I absolutely loved everything! I always love everything Sarah makes, and I really like surprises, so these were perfect as a birthday gift to myself. There were so many times in each box, and you can tell she put each box together with care and thought about the details. The handwritten note with each order is always appreciated, and she even included a free pair of stud earrings. I most definitely will be ordering from her again!


I LOVED this Spring themed mystery box SO MUCH!!! Everything was so beautiful, and PERFECT for Spring!! Sarah’s mystery bags/boxes are always so much fun, and full of gorgeous earrings/accessories!! This shop is amazing, and Sarah is fabulous!! Thank you!!!


Legal imprint