When you order something handmade, it should feel special from the moment it arrives. I put a lot of heart into creating each pair of earrings, and I want that same care to come through in the way I package them. Whether it’s a gift for someone else or a little treat for yourself, I believe the unboxing should feel thoughtful, personal, and just plain fun.  

Here’s a peek at what I include with every order:  

• A handwritten thank you note This is one of my favorite parts. I don’t use a pre-printed message & scrawl my name at the bottom. I just write from the heart and thank you for choosing my shop. 
• A review reminder card I don’t ask for reviews in my handwritten note because I feel like that space should stay personal - just my heartfelt thanks that you picked my shop out of the sea of vendors to shop from. But I do include a small reminder in case you want to share your thoughts once your goodies arrive. 
• Freebies or surprise extras Nearly ever order includes a hairtie that I try to keep seasonally appropriate or at least in my brand colors.  Does anyone notice this but me? Probably not, but I love that little detail.  I also hand tie each hairtie!  I buy big rolls of printed or colored elastic, cut to size, sear the edges, and tie it up!
• Secure + cute packaging Every pair is placed on a card. If you’ve ordered a pair of layered or long fringe earrings along with other items, I’ll tuck that pair into a protective plastic sleeve to keep it safe during shipping. From there, I use one of two packaging methods: either a kraft jewelry box inside a bubble mailer, or a sturdy shipping box filled with paper shred. That’s it! Simple, secure, and a little bit special. I want it to feel like happy mail, not just another package. 

Living so close to the water, I’m extra mindful about the packaging I use. I want every order to feel pretty and protective without creating unnecessary waste. I’ve made intentional choices to keep things eco-conscious while still giving you that happy mail moment. Here’s what that looks like at MFSMI:  

• 🌿 Gift boxes are made in the USA using 100% recycled boxboard and eco fiber fill 
• 🌿 Tissue paper is 100% recycled and part of Green Way® Eco-Friendly Packaging 
• 🌿 Bubble mailers contain at least 50% recycled content and are Global Recycled Standard certified 
• 🌿 Even my earring cards are printed on responsibly sourced paper 

Sustainability matters to me, and I love knowing that my packaging not only looks cute but also makes a smaller impact. 

As a handmade shop owner, I know you could buy earrings anywhere. Packaging is my way of saying “thank you” one more time. I want you to feel excited when your order shows up, not just for the product itself, but because the whole experience made you smile. It also helps me stand out. There are a lot of shops out there, but not everyone takes the time to make it feel personal. When someone opens an MFSMI order and immediately feels appreciated, that’s the best kind of first impression.  

Have Questions or Suggestions?

I love connecting with my customers. If you’ve ever received a package from me, I’d love to hear what stood out to you! And if you’re another small shop owner looking for simple packaging tips, feel free to reach out. I’m always happy to share what’s worked for me. Thanks for supporting handmade and letting me be part of your day. 

xoxo, Sarah My Friend Sarah Made It